ChaseDream

标题: [讨论]问一个关于Operations和supply chain的区别问题. [打印本页]

作者: babyli 时间: 2009-1-19 10:45
标题: [讨论]问一个关于Operations和supply chain的区别问题.

菜鸟看书看到一个问题,不是很明白. 应该没有标准答案,所以拿出来大家讨论一下,还望高手大侠赠金玉良言. 先谢谢了.

Q: One of your friends states that "operations management and supply chain management are primarily of interest to manufacturing firms." Is this true or false? Give some examples to support your answer.

作者: zengxinyu 时间: 2009-5-5 02:32

我的理解，运营管理中会有更多的生产过程管理的质量排程，供应链更多的在于需求和整合焦点在物上。

作者: CedricLi 时间: 2009-5-6 23:09
找下前后文中对于operation management的定义吧。对manufacturer来说应该更多偏向于process方面的管理吧

作者: 雪里蕻小姐 时间: 2009-5-13 22:03

直接的说法就是，前者侧重实际遇到问题的解决，后者类似整个供应链的管理规划．如果您是有实际工作经验的人，应该会很好理解．

作者: Diwen 时间: 2009-6-13 00:04

If you look into positions under operations manager and supply-chain manager, you will have good understanding on the difference between these two management fields.

operations should have function on supply chain management which has enterprise resource intergrated ultimately, on the other hand, it also can be a spot of higher level supply chain.

作者: MadRoc 时间: 2009-6-20 03:19

学术上各个学校分科不一样，但大体上ops和scm重叠的很多，如果针对的是mfg industry的话，ops会给更多的侧重为production/inventory等等，如果针对service industry的话，ops则尤其它侧重，其中一个就是queue。

不过实际上ops的概念很广，（虽然听起来不如scm那么fashion）ops绝对不是生产ops是运营。

scm应该是ops下面的一个分支

作者: babyli 时间: 2009-6-30 12:41

我不怎么理解的地方是: primarily of interest to manufacturing firms.

作为manufacturing firms来说,两者的确都很重要,直接关系企业的盈亏. 这个问题的真正目的倒底在哪里呢?

作者: babyli 时间: 2009-6-30 12:43
现在想想, 制造性企业,或许和SCM更相关. 和OM有点远.

作者: INCHASEDREAM 时间: 2009-8-18 15:22
全是没干过的。。。

作者: kingapple25 时间: 2009-8-30 03:35
我也有此一问，我的专业是SCM，而核心课程是OM

作者: suppma 时间: 2009-9-29 15:08

以下是引用babyli在2009/1/19 10:45:00的发言：

菜鸟看书看到一个问题,不是很明白. 应该没有标准答案,所以拿出来大家讨论一下,还望高手大侠赠金玉良言. 先谢谢了.

"operations management" here means fuctions under strategy, organizations, accounting, process management, SCM etc. all belongs to so called operations management. He points supply chain management here is to emphesis on it.

作者: bestofhq 时间: 2009-10-24 20:43

以下是引用sccdxwj在2009/9/2 17:15:00的发言：
Additionally, we can also say can operations is a part of the supply chain.

Agree, many companies organised Operation Level as the base support function of SCM

作者: babyli 时间: 2009-10-25 18:09

嗯,说得有道理. 可能问题问得就是楼上的意思.如此说来, 问题的statement是错误的, 服务型企业当然也是可以关注的.

我倒是觉得SCM的范畴比OM要大一圈.

OM会狭义地指向某企业的制造,流程,质量等. 而SCM能可包括该企业的上游(客户),自身和下游(供应商和子供应商)的供应链.

作者: CedricLi 时间: 2009-11-7 21:31

operation management concentrates on the process of manufacturing inside the corporation or factories, whereas supply chain management focuses on the control of the flow of martirial,WIP，and finished products. One thing we have to note is that the name of the major in not the conclusive evidence of what the major covers. Some operations majors in US collegs focuses on SCM and logistics.

-- by 会员 sccdxwj (2009/9/2 17:13:00)

the concept of SCM you mentioned here is more suitable to be categorized into "logistics management" rather than SCM coz SCM is not only focus on the materials but more importantly focus on relationship management between up- and down-stream partners. It pays more attention on planning.

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)