ChaseDream

标题: 请问TTGWD4-Q30 [打印本页]

作者: yuminjia    时间: 2009-1-16 13:38
标题: 请问TTGWD4-Q30

TTGWD4-Q30:

Under high pressure and intense heat, graphite, the most stable form of pure carbon, changes into the substance commonly referred to as diamond and remaining this way whether or not the heat and pressure are removed.

 

A.      remaining this way whether or not

B.       remaining like that even as

C.      remaining as such whether or not

D.      remains in this way although

E.       remains thus even when

D哪里错了?


作者: AlienX    时间: 2009-1-16 13:46
D錯在意思上
- "in this way" means "在這方面"...
- LZ多讀幾次會發現句子是想表達"儘管"而不是"雖然"

Hmm...可是E的thus有點怪...

作者: yuminjia    时间: 2009-1-16 15:06
以下是引用AlienX在2009-1-16 13:46:00的发言:
D錯在意思上
- "in this way" means "在這方面"...
- LZ多讀幾次會發現句子是想表達"儘管"而不是"雖然"

Hmm...可是E的thus有點怪...

though 也有尽管的意思啊

是不是in this way上指代不好呢 仔细读前面的话好象没有明确this way 这里的this

不知道自己的想法对不对

请帮助啊


作者: 中国故乡的云    时间: 2009-4-15 12:30

MGMAT的老外解释:Dthis way从逻辑含义上不对。

Here is an excerpt from the new york times

"The transformation is similar to that of carbon. Under high pressure and intense heat, graphite, the most stable form of pure carbon, changes into diamond and remains diamond even when the heat and pressure are taken away."

Ron/ Stacey; I just have a quick question here:

If the part "and remains diamond even when" were to read, "and remains thus even when", will this be correct? or is ""and remains in this way although" better?

答:

"remains thus" would possibly be fine. it sounds a bit stilted and archaic, but i've certainly seen that kind of construction before.
however, it's also quite possible that the gmat will deride that sort of construction as wordy / awkward / unclear (especially "unclear"; the gmat requires a very high standard of precision in SC sentences).
so, the jury is out until we see evidence one way or the other on an official problem.

--

"in this way" would NOT be fine, because no "way" has been described. in fact, no adverb is present at all to be properly parallel to "in this way" (an adverbial construction); diamond is most certainly not a "way" of doing anything.

 


作者: yy179920478    时间: 2009-8-2 12:17
up
作者: pwss    时间: 2009-8-3 16:35

作者: alibaba_2009    时间: 2009-8-4 18:39
UP
作者: priton    时间: 2009-8-19 16:12
up up

作者: frankmfg    时间: 2009-10-4 14:39
Original meaning "whether or not" heat and
pressure are removed. This is bidirectional, heat and pressure can be
removed or not removed.

Choice D is using "although" means heat and pressure are certained to be removed, thus changing the meaning.

Choice E is using "even when" also a bidirectional.

                    
作者: mars_cheung    时间: 2009-11-1 23:52
我选的是 E
我认为句意上说 although 是 虽然,表转折
even when 是 即使,表让步
这里明显“即使”(让步)更合逻辑
作者: dreamroad    时间: 2009-11-28 23:37
有收获
作者: Shinestone    时间: 2009-12-19 23:55
ding mars_cheung !!   我和你想法完全一致 .  不大同意 中国故乡的云 中老外的解释--- 没有wordy 的意味,partly agree 或许有点 unclear .不过总体上来讲,还是应该从句子的意思去揣摩!!!!
作者: lala974    时间: 2011-6-14 03:44
upup
作者: eva731    时间: 2012-2-19 19:14
MGMAT的老外解释:Dthis way从逻辑含义上不对。


"in this way" would NOT be fine, because no "way" has been described. in fact, no adverb is present at all to be properly parallel to "in this way" (an adverbial construction); diamond is most certainly not a "way" of doing anything.



-- by 会员 中国故乡的云 (2009/4/15 12:30:00)



我觉得这个英文解释蛮准确的,gmat的思路可能是这样,我们如果用中文的感觉是“即使”比“尽管”更好一些
作者: liwuruiyun    时间: 2015-8-30 11:43
感谢分享!               
作者: 随Yu而安    时间: 2017-8-4 17:22
og 上说thus是表达 in this way最efficient 的方法




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3