ChaseDream

标题: In @ MSU Broad 去还是不去??? [打印本页]
作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-2 15:47
标题: In @ MSU Broad 去还是不去???

750/101/5 years WE/Manager in a Fortune 10 company/ Top2 undergraduate, poor GPA

Applied 5 programs in R2, from Jan 3rd to Jan 15th

Ross       dinged without interview,                           feel bad, they admitted much less chinese than before,

Wharton  dinged after hub interview                        acceptance rate in interviewees was still low

Yale         dinged without interview                            no comments,

Kellogg     dinged after adcom telephone interview   telephone interview was schedule a little bit late, they seemed to have admitted most already

Sloan        dinged today after hub interview               feel sad, since the acceptance rate in interviewees seems high

2 Top 10 dinged without interview   3 M7 dinged after interview,  should I go Broad or re-apply next year?

R3 deadline 3/3 申了MSU, 中旬电话面试, 他们家网站status也已经变了

给了州内学费(19K) +20K的奖, 只需要出生活费


[此贴子已经被作者于2008-4-8 7:09:36编辑过]
作者: crowkiller    时间: 2008-4-2 16:17
Congs!
作者: jimmyta0899    时间: 2008-4-2 17:46
    Cong!
作者: 慕容楠生    时间: 2008-4-2 19:34
以下是引用iloveit508在2008-4-2 15:47:00的发言：

凌晨接到电话, 收了这个小offer,

R2申了5个, Ross,yale没面试, Kellogg,Wharton面后被拒

R3 deadline 3/3 申了MSU, 中旬电话面试, 他们家网站status也已经变了

给了州内学费(19K) +20K的奖, 只需要出生活费

没想好去不去, 等待R2 最后一所

__这么爽的，，，，，，，从前四个来看，你写的资料和表现不太受TOP10青睐，MSU的全奖，很多TOP10的也拿不到的。。。。。如果等不到，建议去吧，降低风险。。老了再捐个荣誉博士出来。
作者: kachen    时间: 2008-4-2 20:04
congs!
作者: wei_wangyan    时间: 2008-4-2 22:05
恭喜!
作者: Laine    时间: 2008-4-2 23:16
congrats.
作者: yayaduck    时间: 2008-4-3 00:08
MSU的物流很不错
作者: abraham2008    时间: 2008-4-3 00:10

恭喜恭喜，下周来请我吃饭

作者: ohmygod    时间: 2008-4-3 02:09

Cong!

我是上周末接到电话的，奖学金的情况跟LZ差不多。不同的是我是从R2的waitlist get off的。Broad让在4.21之前给决定并交deposit，不知道LZ会去吗？

作者: catcat3014    时间: 2008-4-3 04:53
ohmygod, 先恭喜你从waitlist 上下来， 还想问一下， 你在收到被waitlist消息后有没有做任何followup？ 我也被waitlist了， 可是还没有收到任何消息，心里很着急啊
作者: ohmygod    时间: 2008-4-3 10:18
catcat3014, 我被waitlist之后就写了一封信，分别给 admission director(Jeff)和我的面试官（Paul), 无非就是表表决心和忠心。最后问他们有什么资料需要我update的。 Jeff 一直没有回信， Paul过了一周给我回信，就一句话："如果需要任何信息的话我们会通知你的"。然后再无任何联系，直到上周六给我offer.
作者: Drakedirect    时间: 2008-4-3 10:32
这个学校的物流全美专业排名第二，很强的...恭喜恭喜...

作者: catcat3014    时间: 2008-4-4 00:23
谢谢ohmygod， 那我也只有等了， 我也去和jeff谈过一次，好像没有什么消息。唉， 真是很受折磨啊。
作者: catcat3014    时间: 2008-4-4 00:25
另外， ohmygod, 你能不能说一下你的背景， 他们把我放在waitlist的理由是没有经验. 请问一下你有什么建议吗？ 多谢
[此贴子已经被作者于2008-4-4 0:25:46编辑过]
作者: ohmygod    时间: 2008-4-4 01:05

啊，他们把你waitlist还给你理由了吗？ MS没有给我任何理由啊。

Background:

G/720 T/waiver 本科国内一般重点大学工科毕业，GPA 3.4硕士美国二流学校工科刚刚毕业, GPA 3.75。国内W/E 5.5yrs,经历包括从research到sales,从国企到私企再到外企。

我被wailist以后也很郁闷，因为自我感觉interview做的不错，别的方面似乎也没有特别明显的缺点。但是后来我想到一件事可能跟这个waitlist有关：

说起来也是倒霉催的，我今年总共就申了5所学校，结果在给学校寄资料的时候，有三所学校的title上都稀里糊涂的写了另外一所学校的名字。结果另外两所学校压根儿没有理我，Broad在给我发面试通知的当天下午又给我来了一封email, 信中劈头盖脸问我到底想不想申他们学校了？为什么会把给别的学校的资料给他们寄过去？ 可笑的是我当时才意识到这个愚蠢的错误。结果又是发email又打电话的，总算把这事糊弄过去。现在想想可能还是会有点影响吧？如果是因为这个给waitlist甚至deny了，那我也没什么可说的，自己活该呗。幸运的是他们又给了我一次重新做人的机会，呵呵。

Anyway, 多跟admission office 交流总归不是坏事。 Broad 似乎是挺在意工作经验的，他家的学生平均工作经验都有四五年的，不知道你有几年？如果这方面确实是你一个weakness,我觉得你应该尽量向admission committee 说明虽然你的工作年限少，但是工作质量很高，工作一年顶别人工作两三年的，然后再尽量突出你别的强项。总之尽力忽悠就是了。 Good luck!

最后请问iloveit508大大，你收到正式的admission letter了没有？ 决定去Broad了吗？

作者: littleca    时间: 2008-4-4 01:59
cong!
作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-4 20:39

还没收到正式的package, 估计应该快了

也还没决定是不是去, 再等一下其他学校的结果

作者: catcat3014    时间: 2008-4-4 22:41
ohmygod, thanks a lot for your answer. As a matter of fact, I don't have any real post graduation working experience, I did volunteer work and community service though. This is probably my biggest weakness which I can't do anything about it. Anyway, thank you for your tips and I guess I just have to cross my fingers.
作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-8 07:11

昨天收到broad package, 20000$每年的academic scholarship, 州内学费

今天早上被sloan拒了, 伤心彷徨

作者: Drakedirect    时间: 2008-4-8 09:42


          Business
          Specialty Rankings: Supply Chain/Logistics


    

Ranked in
          2008
        


    
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
            
            
                
                
1Massachusetts Institute of Technology (Sloan)
                    
Cambridge, MA
2Michigan State University (Broad)
                    
East Lansing, MI
3Arizona State University (Carey)
                    
Tempe, AZ

Carnegie Mellon University (Tepper)
                    
Pittsburgh, PA
5Pennsylvania State University--University Park (Smeal)
                    
University Park, PA
6University of Pennsylvania (Wharton)
                    
Philadelphia, PA
7Ohio State University (Fisher)
                    
Columbus, OH
8Purdue University--West Lafayette (Krannert)
                    
West Lafayette, IN

Stanford University
                    
Stanford, CA
10University of Tennessee--Knoxville
                    
Knoxville, TN
USNews 2008最新排名，如果没有更好的offer，这个也不错了...
作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-8 10:53

I know Broad is very strong in SCM, but i have some concern on its overall reputation since I plan to come back to china after mba,  what about the network and career perspective for Broad mba in china?

作者: pwjcathy    时间: 2008-4-8 12:21
以下是引用iloveit508在2008-4-2 15:47:00的发言：

750/101/5 years WE/Manager in a Fortune 10 company/ Top2 undergraduate, poor GPA

Applied 5 programs in R2, from Jan 3rd to Jan 15th

Ross       dinged without interview,                           feel bad, they admitted much less chinese than before,

Wharton  dinged after hub interview                        acceptance rate in interviewees was still low

Yale         dinged without interview                            no comments,

Kellogg     dinged after adcom telephone interview   telephone interview was schedule a little bit late, they seemed to have admitted most already

Sloan        dinged today after hub interview               feel sad, since the acceptance rate in interviewees seems high

2 Top 10 dinged without interview   3 M7 dinged after interview,  should I go Broad or re-apply next year?

R3 deadline 3/3 申了MSU, 中旬电话面试, 他们家网站status也已经变了

给了州内学费(19K) +20K的奖, 只需要出生活费


选择也许在于lz的career goal 和决心有多大：

1。msu的全奖使得其roi大幅提升，esp以后想在supply chain 方面继续发展。

2。如果不甘心，还是可以try another year, you are still young.

Best wishes!

作者: ppeema    时间: 2008-4-8 12:25
如果是做SCM，MSU是个非常好的学校
作者: 慕容楠生    时间: 2008-4-8 12:40
从更新的背景来看，楼主会觉得有点委屈。。。
作者: hswdream    时间: 2008-4-8 17:35
以下是引用iloveit508在2008-4-2 15:47:00的发言：

750/101/5 years WE/Manager in a Fortune 10 company/ Top2 undergraduate, poor GPA

Applied 5 programs in R2, from Jan 3rd to Jan 15th

Ross       dinged without interview,                           feel bad, they admitted much less chinese than before,

Wharton  dinged after hub interview                        acceptance rate in interviewees was still low

Yale         dinged without interview                            no comments,

Kellogg     dinged after adcom telephone interview   telephone interview was schedule a little bit late, they seemed to have admitted most already

Sloan        dinged today after hub interview               feel sad, since the acceptance rate in interviewees seems high

2 Top 10 dinged without interview   3 M7 dinged after interview,  should I go Broad or re-apply next year?

R3 deadline 3/3 申了MSU, 中旬电话面试, 他们家网站status也已经变了

给了州内学费(19K) +20K的奖, 只需要出生活费


Ross       dinged without interview,  so wierd

作者: hswdream    时间: 2008-4-8 17:39
lz should apply for some top 10-20 b-schools.
作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-8 18:31

to hswdream :

what did you mean by saying "lz should apply for some top 10-20 b-schools. "? 

schools rank between ross and msu?

作者: iloveit508    时间: 2008-4-8 18:32
I don't know why ross did not offer me a interview, ross seams strange this year, interviewed and admitted much less than the previous year
作者: abbery    时间: 2008-4-9 00:06
最好去！
作者: Whitney    时间: 2008-4-9 00:11
try another year, you are still young.
作者: abraham2008    时间: 2008-4-9 00:42
以下是引用iloveit508在2008-4-8 18:32:00的发言：
I don't know why ross did not offer me a interview, ross seams strange this year, interviewed and admitted much less than the previous year

Hi, buddy, do not be sad. If you can wait, try again with a good Toefl score. You can achieve M7.

Support you!

作者: irisfang    时间: 2008-4-9 00:49

Support you!

作者: WinstonLTyy    时间: 2008-6-1 10:59

楼主决定了吗?

本人也在考虑申请Broad,请楼主和各位大虾帮我判断下可能性.(当然,essay这些也是很大的决定因素)

（本人背景，international shipping,1 year in a foreign corporate, 3 years till now in a state-owned company, 1 year as customer service, 2 years as sales & marketing, 1 year till now as General Manager Assistant. Both companies are branch offices, not head quarters. GMAT 740/5.5, Toefl 110)





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3