552.Once the economic and social usefulness of the motor car was demonstrated and with its superiority to the horse being proved, much of the early hostility to it in rural regions disappeared.
(A) and with its superiority to the horse being
(B) and its superiority over the horse had been
(C) and its superiority to the horse
(D) its superiority over the horse
(E) with its superiority to the horse having been
白勇语法答案是B，大全解释是C
白勇的解释：C选项 and连接once从句和名词短语its superiority，两者形式不对称（P128）
大全解释：In choice C, the best answer, the main predication usefulness…was demonstrated is paralleled by superiority [was] proved, with [was] omitted as understood. In choices A and E, the prepositional phrase beginning with…violates this parallelism; in A, B, and E, the verb forms being, had been, and having been are not consistent with the simple past tense in was demonstrated. The phrase superiority over is unidiomatic in B and D: x is superior to y, not over y. D is also faulty because no function word, such as the conjunction and, grammatically connects its superiority… to the rest of the sentence.
我问一下这里是否有Be动词省略的问题
如果选C的话，代入原句为：Once the economic and social usefulness of the motor car was demonstrated and its superiority to the horse (was )proved, much of the early hostility to it in rural regions disappeared.
想问一下是不是任何情况下 A is....and B (is)....都成立呢？ 或者是单复数必须统一
顶一下！
我问一下这里是否有Be动词省略的问题
如果选C的话，代入原句为：Once the economic and social usefulness of the motor car was demonstrated and its superiority to the horse (was )proved, much of the early hostility to it in rural regions disappeared.
想问一下是不是任何情况下 A is....and B (is)....都成立呢？ 或者是单复数必须统一
谁能回答啊
顶一下！
我问一下这里是否有Be动词省略的问题
如果选C的话，代入原句为：Once the economic and social usefulness of the motor car was demonstrated and its superiority to the horse (was )proved, much of the early hostility to it in rural regions disappeared.
想问一下是不是任何情况下 A is....and B (is)....都成立呢？ 或者是单复数必须统一
谁能回答啊
我认为是单复数统一的
其实是这样的，这是一种省略 当平行后面部分与前面重复的时候，重复的部分就会被省略
在OG 中有好多题就是 TO DO S.TH AND DO S.TH 当然这实在没有起歧义的情况下
如果会出现歧义了，那么WAS TO 这些原先被省略的就必须加上了
VOTE FOR C
应该选C吧...
觉得B的had been不对,如果从理解角度上来说,原句的意思应该是当两个东西同时成立时,什么什么什么...所以这两个东西是并列的.
had been不是表示过去的过去么...
我这么理解是不是浅显了点。。。
应该是C，因为很明显，后面的(was)是省略了---在ＯＧ里出现过很多次类此情况。而Ｂ逻辑上如果硬要理解的话，就是说在汽车的经济性和社会性作用被确认之前，人们已经确认了它的速度；但是ＯＧ一贯没有要求这么啰嗦的去理解，而且用ｏｎｃｅ和ａｎｄ平行，这个理解也就更加别扭。
| 欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) | Powered by Discuz! X3.3 |