ChaseDream

标题: OG11-42(help!!!) [打印本页]

作者: benja 时间: 2007-4-29 18:12
标题: OG11-42(help!!!)

Mourdet Winery: Danville Winery's new wine was introduced to compete with our popular wine, is sold in a distinctive tall, black bottle. Danville uses a similsr bottle. Thus, it is likely that many customers intending to buy our wine will mistakenly buy theirs instead.

Danville Winery: Not so. The two bottles can be readily distinguished : the label on ous, but not on theirs, is gold coloured.

which of the following, if true, most undermines Danville Winery's response?

A. Gold is the background color on the label of many of the wines produced by Danville Winery.

B. When the bottles are viewed side by side, Danville Winery's bottle is perceptibly taller than Danville Winery's

C. Danville Winery, unlike Danville Winery, displays its wines' label prominently in advertisements.

D. It is common for occational purchasers to buy a bottle of wine on the basis of a general impression of the most obvious feature of the bottle.

E. Many popular wines are sold in bottles of a standard design.

The answer provided by OG is D, i could understand now.

But why E is wrong, i don't know why? Because if E is true, then the two bottles with a standard design will be difficult to distinguished.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-4-29 22:44:25编辑过]

作者: elithian 时间: 2007-4-29 20:46

如果E正确，那每种酒之间就都不能通过形状辨认了，那么你还凭什么怪我用和你形状一样的酒瓶呢？

题外话：：）mm好酒的话就知道，葡萄酒瓶的大致形状是和酒的种类、产区联系在一起的：）

作者: fy_w 时间: 2007-4-30 20:13
这个题的分析是这样的：
MW公司认为顾客想买MW公司的产品，但是会把误把DW公司的产品误认为是MW公司的，因为DW公司的瓶子形状，与MW公司相似。（潜在的推理是：顾客根据瓶子的形状判断是哪个公司的）

DW公司反驳说，两个瓶子是可以根据商标区分的。（潜在的推理是：顾客根据商标区分）

如果DW公司的推理是错误的，那么顾客不是根据商标区分的，而是根据形状来区分的。

E。选项，popular wine, 这个概念，文中都没涉及，文中并没有说明，MW公司的产品或者DW公司的产品，哪一个是 popular. 所以属于无关。

作者: benja 时间: 2007-5-1 18:23
谢谢LSs

作者: yinlixiao 时间: 2008-8-3 04:58
fy_w的解释有误。
首先题目是有提到“popular wine"这个概念。
再次题目的理解是DW和MW都有“popular wine"。

E选项是无关的，因为它指出的这些“popular wine"是用“bottles of a standard design“，而文中里比较的两种wines用的是“a distinctive tall, black bottle”.

作者: hihello 时间: 2008-8-3 10:53

同意楼上的观点。

作者: lucky_fs 时间: 2009-7-28 12:15

答案(D)我可以理解,但是说到"用其他方法来达到鉴别两种wine的目的",B.项 When the bottles are viewed side by side, Danville Winery's bottle is perceptibly taller than Danville Winery's不是也是提供了一种从hight鉴别的方法么?!不是也削弱了DW的用label鉴别的方法么?为什么不可以选呢?

OG解释上说是因为又提供了一种新的方法(我理解他的意思是不同于MW和DW的方法),但是题目问的是关于DW的回答,关MW的方法什么事呢?那MW的形状鉴别发和从hight鉴别不都是不同于DW的方法么?为何不选B?

我的问题肯定存在白痴的地方,请各位不吝赐教,谢啦谢啦

作者: gracezz 时间: 2010-4-25 16:00
还是不明白D

D 说偶尔有人买酒是根据酒的最显著的impression.那不正是DW说的方法吗，那不是加强吗？就不是undermine了呀

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)