ChaseDream

标题: [求助]GWD26-Q38,看过讨论但有疑问 [打印本页]

作者: michelle1021    时间: 2007-4-28 15:49
标题: [求助]GWD26-Q38,看过讨论但有疑问

Finally reaching a decision on an issue that has long been politically charged

in the Pacific Northwest, politicians decided to postpone by at least five years

an ambitious plan to protect wild salmon and other endangered fish, instead

of which they proposed a series of smaller steps, by which they intend to

protect the fish.

A.     politicians decided to postpone by at least five years an ambitious plan

to protect wild salmon and other endangered fish, instead of which they

proposed a series of smaller steps, by which they intend

B.     politicians decided to postpone by at least five years an ambitious plan

to protect wild salmon and other endangered fish, proposing instead a

series of smaller steps intended.

C.    
                        
politicians decided to postpone by at least five years an ambitious plan

for protecting wild salmon and other endangered fish, and instead they

proposed a series of smaller steps, intending.

D.     an ambitious plan to protect wild salmon and other endangered fish was

postponed by politicians, who instead proposed a series of smaller

steps, intending.

E.      an ambitious plan to protect wild salmon and other endangered fish has

been postponed by politicians, proposing instead a series of smaller

steps intended.

答案:B,我选C. C为什么错了啊?AND两边这么平行, 而且现在也有很多是FOR+DOING 的用法啊.而且B里面第二句怎么看都不对啊?


作者: cancerbobo    时间: 2007-4-28 17:37
C中they应该省略
作者: michelle1021    时间: 2007-4-28 20:17
oh,对哈,谢谢楼上的
作者: elithian    时间: 2007-4-28 20:30

Reasons:

1)C选项and前后是并列关系,不是转折关系

2)对比的是宾语proposal,而不是整个句子--与原文结构有出入

3)instead一般不放在句首修饰整个句子,类似though(个人观点,仅做参考)


作者: jzq    时间: 2007-4-28 22:25
C里还有一个最明显的错误就是for protecting
作者: colorful_na    时间: 2007-7-12 11:41
kan
作者: 瞳色九月    时间: 2007-7-12 12:18
ambitious plan to protect要好于for protecting  OG上有例子
作者: dan2007    时间: 2008-3-23 23:34
up
作者: dan2007    时间: 2008-3-31 04:35
up
作者: raiden_lee    时间: 2008-5-22 14:43

Og11-84

Under the Safe Drinking Water Act, the Environmental Protection Agency is required either to approve individual state plans for controlling the discharge of wastes into underground water or that they enforce their own plan for states without adequate regulations.

(A) that they enforce their

(B) for enforcing their

(C) they should enforce their

(D) it should enforce its

(E) to enforce its

Og上ms plan for 和plan to 都有阿...如何选择???


作者: ad264    时间: 2008-5-22 17:13
Og11-84 plan for接對象,不是計畫要作什麼。

所以此GWD中 plan to V是正確的(看字典也是)

C還有兩個錯。

    

-
        
steps were INTENDED by politicians... they didn't intend
anything themselves -> need passive form here.

- we should have BUT and not AND, because of the constrast of ideas
"INSTEAD



我也是選了C所以google 了一下

作者: january_ye    时间: 2008-7-10 17:12
up
作者: yzhao26    时间: 2009-3-4 11:22
up
作者: tiffany1102    时间: 2009-4-18 22:25

up.....


作者: pwss    时间: 2009-7-31 21:05
up
作者: yingsuanna06    时间: 2010-5-4 15:50
[quote]

-
steps were INTENDED by politicians... they didn't intend
anything themselves -> need passive form here.





可是我觉得intenting在这里做伴随壮语,逻辑主语应该是前一句的they,即politicians,所以用intending 应该没有问题

作者: zhaoruihan    时间: 2010-5-23 12:21
关于C项中,intending的修饰对象,也有问题:
intending可以看作v-ing放在句子末尾产生修饰对象的歧义
[1] 修饰steps,说steps intending---,steps做了intending 的逻辑主语/动作发出者,steps intending to protect fish,不合逻辑,因而就错啦
[2] 修饰politicians,也就是全句的大主语,说politicians intending to protect fish,合乎逻辑,对
作者: 程喷喷    时间: 2010-7-5 14:30
我猜是不是instead的位置导致表达不精确了啊C....
作者: raremagic    时间: 2011-4-25 22:13
C末尾的intending并无歧义...逻辑主语是前一主谓宾分句的主语they,但是逻辑含义上却存在问题:
可以理解为they proposed a series of smaller steps,同时they intend to protect fish, 没有表达出原句的steps是用来protect fish的含义
B中的 ....steps intended to protect 就表明了steps是用来保护鱼类的
作者: alisaxu    时间: 2011-7-22 21:43
谁能讲一下instead的用法啊
作者: kun5850    时间: 2011-10-30 15:48
我觉得raremagic 的回答是正确的:就是语义的问题后面是 to protect the fish 逻辑主语显然steps 要好于politicians
是这种措施保护鱼不是政客保护鱼。请指教
作者: liuqianyu33    时间: 2011-11-12 21:13
那B 对是不是也太牵强了呢?




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3