ChaseDream

标题: [offer]: marketing@UIUC [打印本页]

作者: birdxxx    时间: 2007-3-15 21:07
标题: [offer]: marketing@UIUC

只申请了这么一个marketing program,今天收到了正式的email通知,之前有面试,面试之后就有口头的offer了。

本来不打算报的,因为要decline,但是看今天offer这么多我就也凑个热闹

我没有marketing的background,上学和工作都和marketing不相干,所以可以鼓励一下未来跨专业申marketing的人吧,不过有一个marketing professor帮我写了推荐信,可能有很大帮助


作者: buckeyeTD    时间: 2007-3-15 21:19

You want to decline it? Marketing has a much better job market than IS does. Anyway, congrats!


作者: birdxxx    时间: 2007-3-15 21:43
以下是引用buckeyeTD在2007-3-15 21:19:00的发言:

You want to decline it? Marketing has a much better job market than IS does. Anyway, congrats!

,several people (including some marketing professors) try to persuade me by the better job market too.

I read again the two papers about IS academic job market cometqq  posted last year. And I heard a lot about the severe job market and the so-called identity crisis in IS discipline. But I still choose to join an IS program just because I studied and worked in this field for many years and I think my interest, and maybe my strength, is here.

Based on my limited working experience as an IT consultant, I think IS should be an important discipline in business school, but how comes current difficulty? Many professors said it is because of the burst of IT bubble, but I think at least it is partly because of the immaturity of this discipline. Maybe this kind of immaturity means also an opportunity for us...

不是有个美国人说过,Crisis(危机) in Chinese has two words, one means danger, the other means opportunity.


作者: ProfCPA    时间: 2007-3-15 21:57
Glad to see your commitment to the research..  I think that weighs over the hardness of the job market.

作者: buckeyeTD    时间: 2007-3-15 22:03
Don't make a blind decision. You need to do a very informed one since you face two very distinctive career choices. I don't doubt the advantage you will take from the disciplinary inertia, but an innovative change may make you more efficient down the road, not to mention the material return.
作者: birdxxx    时间: 2007-3-15 22:27
Thanks a lot for ProfCPA's encouragement and BuckeyeTD's advice.  Making choice is always hard, especially under information limitation and uncertainty...
[此贴子已经被作者于2007-3-15 22:32:35编辑过]

作者: beautifulmind    时间: 2007-3-15 23:14

支持!


作者: Viky9    时间: 2007-3-15 23:32

Man, If I were in your position, I would choose Austin too.

If someone are to rejuvenate the IS field, they should be you Austin people!


作者: phd2007    时间: 2007-3-16 01:18
absolutely no idea about UT-Austin IS program. I'd say that UT-Dallas has better IS program than UT-Austin now.

作者: papawaigo    时间: 2007-3-16 01:32
以下是引用phd2007在2007-3-16 1:18:00的发言:
absolutely no idea about UT-Austin IS program. I'd say that UT-Dallas has better IS program than UT-Austin now.

     I doubt. UT-Dallas better than UT-Austin in MIS?
作者: phd2007    时间: 2007-3-16 03:10
商学院的FALCUTY认钱啊,去看看UT-DALLAS的 IS  FACULTY  的名单吧...

作者: birdxxx    时间: 2007-3-16 16:53

yes, UT Dallas grows very fast in recent years, and the faculties there are strong.

I just did not apply for it jsut because the application fee is so expensive for international student...


[此贴子已经被作者于2007-3-16 17:12:08编辑过]

作者: martinqiu    时间: 2007-4-14 04:33
If you are go to UT Austion, you will change your mind the first day
you are in the IS program. Say hi to Winston and see how many Chinese
students he has hoarded.  What? he is not your advisor? That is even
worse.

Anyway, you still have chance to do some e-marketing
related research. I saw so many IS  Ph.D.coming to marketing for
jobs
[此贴子已经被作者于2007-4-14 4:34:45编辑过]

作者: birdxxx    时间: 2007-4-15 11:11
以下是引用martinqiu在2007-4-14 4:33:00的发言:
If you are go to UT Austion, you will change your mind the first day
you are in the IS program. Say hi to Winston and see how many Chinese
students he has hoarded.  What? he is not your advisor? That is even
worse.

Anyway, you still have chance to do some e-marketing
related research. I saw so many IS  Ph.D.coming to marketing for
jobs

Thanks martin,  I noticed the extremely large proportion of Chinese students in Austin's IS even before I apply. But does it matter much? At least some of their past Chinese graduates placed well, and Dr.Whinston is really a leader in eco tracks of IS research.

I know that IS overlaps with marketing research in Ecommerce field and some IS professors also publish in marketing journals (Actually that is why I apply for a marketing program even without any marketing experience). But are there IS PhDs hunt for marketing positions?


作者: toil    时间: 2007-4-15 15:19
精神可佳,NNNNNNNNNNNNN
作者: zephre    时间: 2007-4-16 23:15
以下是引用birdxxx在2007-4-15 11:11:00的发言:

Thanks martin,  I noticed the extremely large proportion of Chinese students in Austin's IS even before I apply. But does it matter much? At least some of their past Chinese graduates placed well, and Dr.Whinston is really a leader in eco tracks of IS research.

I know that IS overlaps with marketing research in Ecommerce field and some IS professors also publish in marketing journals (Actually that is why I apply for a marketing program even without any marketing experience). But are there IS PhDs hunt for marketing positions?

I think martinqiu is referring to IS Ph.d. students who target industry. I do know a lot of IS phd students went to general consulting firm or marketing consulting firm, instead of doing IT counsulting or IT Audit. When it comes to academy, IS phd students definitely hunt for IS positions.

I dont know why people here are so harsh and mean to IS major. Are you guys from IS major? How much do you know about IS? I guess most of what you said were heard from others. And one case does not represent the whole population!! I dont think a strategy major or markteting major can comment on IS. Don't say stupid things here to mislead people. Stop gossiping.

I support birdxxx's decision. It is your life, you decision! If I were you, I would do the same thing.


[此贴子已经被作者于2007-4-16 23:16:00编辑过]





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3