ChaseDream

标题: 逗号done 请问在这里是什么用法? [打印本页]

作者: idcannotbefound    时间: 2021-12-1 14:33
标题: 逗号done 请问在这里是什么用法?
gwd tn24:
The ancient Anasazi harvested such native desert vegetation as the purple-flowered bee plant, what they now commonly call wild spinach in northern Arizona and other parts of the southwestern United States.

A     what they now commonly call
B     a plant that they now commonly call
C     now commonly called
D     and is now commonly called
E     which it is now commonly called


答案C
此题C选项: 如果是定语从句 which is now commonly called,which is可以省略?


                  如果called 是就近修饰plant,但是中间有个逗号,可以这么用吗?     去掉逗号才说得通吧



作者: miltond    时间: 2021-12-1 15:24
C的Which is可以省略啊,或者说,做SC题不能按照死规则来,而要选出一个相对最好的,最没有硬伤的答案

A和B里都有they,但前文的复数名词就是Anasazi了,这种古代人类不能用now commonly吧,更不能叫他们菠菜吧

D选项 and is 也不对,and前后平行的话,需要加主语那种植物,如果不加这个植物的主语,那is的主语就变成了and前面那半句话的主语Anasazi了,Anasazi不能是菠菜啊 (或者说,D选项这种省略and后半句的主语所带来的伤害 比C选项省略which is带来的伤害大的多的多,实属硬伤 )

至于E,如果要用非限制性定语的形式,which前面有逗号,有个purple-flowered bee plant,权且OK吧,但which后面跟了个 it 就不对了啊,这也是硬伤

所以,相比ABDE带来的硬伤来说,C这种省略which is的做法就不算什么了,选它





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3