ChaseDream

标题: 揽瓜阁做题小分队 第12天 预测日食装置-第一台模拟计算机 [打印本页]

作者: 小白斩鸡    时间: 2021-4-11 22:23
标题: 揽瓜阁做题小分队 第12天 预测日食装置-第一台模拟计算机

请大家在本帖回复:
1. 文章大概结构
2. 自己写的答案
解析明晚微信群里公布



In 1901, divers exploring the remains of a shipwreck off the coast of Greece discovered a contraption believed to have been used by Ancient Greeks to predict solar eclipses. The Antikythera Mechanism was composed of a fixed ring dial representing the 12 months of the Egyptian calendar and an inner ring representing the 12 zodiac signs. Inside, a complex assembly of bronze gears mechanically replicated the irregular motions of the Moon caused by its elliptical orbit around the Earth through the use of two gear-wheels, one of which was slightly off-center, connected by a pin. Regarded as the world’s first analog computer, the Antikythera Mechanism involved remarkably intricate physics considering that, only 300 years earlier, the Ancient Greeks still believed the world was flat. Accurately predicting lunar and solar eclipses, as well as solar, lunar, and planetary positions, it predated similar technology by 1,000 years. The timing and nature of its existence remains one of science’s great puzzles to this day. How and by whom was it created?

Today, scientists understand much more about the complexities of the orbital revolutions that cause solar eclipses to occur; for instance, the Earth’s orbit around the Sun is also elliptical such that, depending on the time of year, the Earth is gradually traveling nearer to or farther from the Sun. Further, since the plane of the Moon’s revolution around the Earth is not the same as the plane of the Earth’s revolution around the Sun, all calculations predicting a solar eclipse must be completed in three dimensions. While in modern times the use of satellites, telescopes, and other high-tech equipment has greatly enhanced our capacity for such calculations, when the Antikythera Mechanism was created, the sole source of information available to scientists was observation of the night sky. It is thus not surprising that, under certain circumstances, the device is inaccurate by up to 38 degrees; what is astonishing is that the device is remarkably accurate over a wide range of conditions.

Recent analysis dating the device to 205 BC, earlier than previously thought, suggests that the eclipse prediction mechanism was based not on Greek trigonometry but on Babylonian arithmetical methods borrowed by the Greeks. This conjecture makes plausible Cicero’s claim that Archimedes created the mechanism, as Greek trigonometry was nonexistent in 205 BC.


1. Which of the following best describes the relationship of the second paragraph to the passage as a whole?
(A) It provides evidence to support the main idea introduced earlier in the passage.
(B) It presents a hypothesis that is rejected in the final paragraph of the passage.
(C) It offers an example of a theory proposed in the first paragraph of the passage.
(D) It suggests a solution to a problem described earlier in the passage.
(E) It draws a parallel between two phenomena discussed in the passage.

2. It can be inferred from the third paragraph that
(A) the Ancient Greeks were more sophisticated than most people believe
(B) Babylonian arithmetical methods predate Greek trigonometry
(C) the greatest thinker in Ancient Greece was Archimedes
(D) Information obtainable by modern-day telescopes was also available in Ancient Greece
(E) the Antikythera Mechanism was more likely to accurately predict a solar eclipse than modern day technology

3. According to the passage, which of the following statements about the Antikythera Mechanism is true?
(A) It was created by Archimedes.
(B) It is 1,000 years old.
(C) It was created in the 1900s.
(D) It was the world’s first digital computer.
(E) It could be 38 degrees inaccurate.

4. The passage suggests which of the following about models that predict solar eclipses?
(A) Until the last century, it was impossible to create models that would accurately predict solar eclipses.
(B) When it was discovered in 1901, the Antikythera Mechanism was the only model available to predict solar eclipses.
(C) The Antikythera Mechanism is not the only model that attempts to predict solar eclipses.
(D) The calendar months and the zodiac signs are both important for tracking the irregular motions of the Moon.
(E) The unpredictability of such models makes them suitable only as curiosities or antiques.

参考答案,做完才看 :)



作者: N0ire    时间: 2021-4-11 22:50
7min
主旨:介绍安提基特拉机械的构成、作用和背后的原理
P1: 安提基特拉机械于1901年被发现,它是古希腊人制作的用于预测日蚀的装置,谁、如何制作是个谜团;
P2: 今昔对比:如今借助各种设备我们可以进行大量的日蚀预测模拟,而古老的安提基克拉机械竟也有一定的准确度;
P3: 近期研究显示,日蚀预测装置很可能是基于古巴比伦的算术学,因而西塞罗宣称阿基米德创造了机械学也可能存疑。

EBEC
作者: rs曦曦    时间: 2021-4-11 23:57
DBAC
作者: LeenaVS    时间: 2021-4-12 00:47
CBDA

作者: Claire薇荇    时间: 2021-4-12 05:30
discovered a machine that can predict solar eclipses, the question scientists are wondering is how and by whom it was created - nowadays scientists understand more about solar eclipses with technologies, the machine discovered is astonishing accurate. However, when it's created, there is no such sources of technology. - recent analysis indicates the machine was based on Babylonian methods, not Greeks.
ABEC
作者: connie_123    时间: 2021-4-12 09:26
abec
作者: 速水愛媛    时间: 2021-4-12 10:01
CBAC
作者: CCCGO    时间: 2021-4-12 10:24
EBEC
作者: miemie_yang    时间: 2021-4-12 10:39
答案:E B A E
介绍了The Antikythera Mechanism的构成,以及对预测日食的功能和作用,通过现今的技术反比出这个device的准确性,最近发现了她是基于Babylonian的,Archimedes穿凿了这个device
作者: irisville    时间: 2021-4-12 11:08
dbea
作者: HHHHRane    时间: 2021-4-12 11:30
CBAC

第一段:1901年,在希腊海下的沉船残骸中发现了第一台测日食的模拟计算机;讲了它的主要构造,以及它能做准确的预测。它具体是什么时候被谁造出来的至今仍是谜团
第二段:引入了当今准确测日食的仪器的例子,与上述的模拟计算机做对比,强调该模拟计算机在古代条件缺乏下仍能的精准性。
第三段:近期的研究结果推翻了之前的理论。

作者: LouisTan    时间: 2021-4-12 11:48
ABAA
作者: 再战请勿拦    时间: 2021-4-12 12:28
abac
请问下大家 plausible相当于是极不确定的肯定吗?还是就相当于是否定呢?
作者: Sibaiyuan    时间: 2021-4-12 14:35
ABEC
作者: 英语爱我我爱英语    时间: 2021-4-12 14:45
7min20s ABDC
作者: Jack.Lu    时间: 2021-4-12 15:36
EBAC,
P1:Antikythera的发现,以及他的原理,结尾提出疑问
P2:今天能够预测日食的原因,而且Antikythera很精准
P3:总结,谁制造了Antikythera
作者: yyking625    时间: 2021-4-12 20:12
ABAC
作者: 断了的弦    时间: 2021-4-12 20:33
ABED 13''
作者: 半日大哥    时间: 2021-4-12 21:12
用时5分50秒
ABEC

作者: sekicc    时间: 2021-4-12 23:11
1. 引出主题
2. 举一个例子
3. 举另一个例子

ABEC
作者: 星v座v书v上    时间: 2021-4-12 23:26
DAAC
作者: 狒狒小姐    时间: 2021-4-13 05:13
DBBC
作者: CNJYD    时间: 2021-4-13 08:18
EAAD
作者: Ataitaitai    时间: 2021-4-13 08:47
ABAC
作者: RxxMewo    时间: 2021-4-13 09:44
在1901年AM方法与预测solar eclipse 但是how和谁发明的并不清楚 - 当今有很多更高级的手段,比较来看AM方法也有一定的准确度 - 最近发现solar eclipse的预测方法应该是base on比Greek trigonometry更早的理论
ABDC 9min
作者: LindsayPark    时间: 2021-4-13 20:17
ABEC
P1:有人发现了AM这个东西,讲述了它又多厉害
P2:和现在当然比不了了,但是考虑到当时的情况,AM真的非常厉害了
P3:猜测了一下到底谁发明的

作者: ccccherry    时间: 2021-4-13 20:24
DBEC

作者: vivianjy    时间: 2021-4-13 21:30
ADEC
作者: xulexuan    时间: 2021-4-14 14:11
dbac
作者: _Salaxy_    时间: 2021-4-14 15:27
CBAC
作者: yutingw    时间: 2021-4-15 16:09
EBEC
作者: JOEY要上博科尼    时间: 2021-4-16 23:59
1
作者: 大大大kk    时间: 2021-4-17 11:46
dbac
作者: 2022Tiramisu    时间: 2021-4-18 18:43
ECEC
作者: sssszzzzxccsc    时间: 2021-4-21 19:38
BBAC
作者: SchodingerCat    时间: 2021-5-6 23:41
ABEC
作者: 张晴雨    时间: 2021-5-8 09:50
我的答案:AAEC
正确答案:ABEC
用时:11分钟
作者: 690387114    时间: 2021-6-19 10:17
ABEC
作者: 清影嘿嘿    时间: 2021-10-25 16:00
day12

作者: 大月亮cyn    时间: 2021-10-27 17:34
Day12 ABEC
作者: B及站士    时间: 2023-10-7 22:48
P1. 安堤基特拉機械(後面簡稱安機)在1901發現, 是古希臘人用來預測日蝕的工具, 功能十分的準確
P2. 講述現代科學家對日蝕有更多的瞭解,但那是基於科技的改良觀測到的。對比古時的人們只能觀測夜空, 安機在大多數範圍下都很準確(只有38度不準確)
P3. 新的研究表示安機是西元前205年的產物, 基於巴比倫數學而非希臘三角學 -> 故支持安機是阿基米德發明的說法
-
P1.
1. Context: “The Antikythera Mechanism” discovered in 1901 – Ancient Greeks to predict solar eclipses
2. Elaborate:
a fixed ring dial & an inner ring– the Egyptian calendar & the 12 zodiac signs
bronze gears – the motions of the Moon – elliptical orbit around the Earth
3. Intermediate: “The Antikythera Mechanism” – accurately predicting lunar and solar eclipses and thier positions – one of science’s great puzzles to this day

P2
1.Modern scientists: understand much more about the orbital revolutions that cause solar eclipses to occur
2. Example:
the Earth’s orbit around the Sun is elliptical – the Earth is traveling nearer to or farther from the Sun
the plane of the Moon’s revolution ≠ the plane of the Earth’s revolution – solar eclipse prediction needs three dimensions
3. Comparison: modern times (high-tech equipment) vs. the Antikythera Mechanism (observation of the night sky) -> though inaccurate by up to 38 degrees , the device is still accurate over a wide range of conditions

P3
1. Recent analysis: the eclipse prediction mechanism – based on Babylonian arithmetical methods (not from Greek trigonometry)
2. Conclusion: this conjecture – support the claims that Archimedes created the mechanism (Greek trigonometry was nonexistent in 205 BC)

作者: joliajjj    时间: 2023-12-6 10:23
文章结构:
P1:AM的由来、作用机理
P2:当代设备测量日食、AM一定的准确性得到证实
P3:eclipse prediction mechanism的确定时间
ABEC





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3