ChaseDream

标题: 揽瓜阁做题小分队 第11天 传记作者与传记对象 [打印本页]

作者: 小白斩鸡    时间: 2021-4-10 21:56
标题: 揽瓜阁做题小分队 第11天 传记作者与传记对象
请大家在本帖回复:
1. 文章大概结构
2. 自己写的答案
解析明晚微信群里公布


One often hears that biographies are autobiographies, that the biographer is always writing about himself. On the contrary, serious biographers seek and welcome the unfamiliar, however troublesome to account for. Ron Chernow, the author of rich biographies of the American businessmen J.P. Morgan and John D. Rockefeller, remarks that biographers “like to stub their toes on hard, uncomfortable facts strewn in their paths.” Such encounters with the unaccountable are opportunities for breaking out and breaking through, in new directions, to fresh understanding.

One also often hears that biographers must like their subjects. That would of course rule out such vastly important subjects as Hitler or Stalin. In practice, the biographer must like the subject not as a person but as a subject. Some are good subjects for the author, some bad. And what makes one subject better than another for any particular biographer varies dramatically. Some of the reasons are purely practical. Does the subject need a biography? Are the materials available? How much time is needed? A biographer’s knowledge and ability also determine the choice. Great scientists are great subjects, but can one write about their achievements with insight and authority? Personal idiosyncrasies matter, too. Biographers tend to be attracted to subjects who display particular personality traits, whether they be ambition, cruelty, ingenuity, or any other characteristic that separates a potential subject from the multitudes.

In choosing a subject, the biographer’s main question should be, “Can an effective book be made out of this person’s life?” Day after day for years, the biographer will try to untangle chronology, compress relationships without distorting them, and keep the main narrative clear while carrying forward several intricate strands of the subject’s life. What pushes most biographers on in this endeavor is not necessarily affection for the subject but the feeling that they are writing a good book.


1. It can be inferred that the author makes which of the following assumptions about biographies?
A. Their main purpose is to inform readers about key aspects of the subjects’ personalities.
B. Only subjects who share traits with biographers make good subjects for biographies.
C. Compelling biographies cannot be written about ordinary citizens.
D. The biographer’s credibility with readers is a factor in the critical success of a biography.
E. Practical considerations are most important in the selection of a subject for a biography.


2. The author is primarily concerned with
A. persuading biographers to change their methods
B. refuting some common beliefs about a particular literary genre
C. arguing against continued reform of a historical endeavor
D. refuting an outdated theory of a particular literary genre
E. describing the working methods of certain authors


3. The author mentions "Ron Chernow" most probably in order to
A. provide a counterexample to a general claim about biography
B. illustrate a questionable assertion regarding biography
C. establish a favorable comparison with an established biographer
D. underscore the importance of research in biography
E. challenge a new approach to biography



参考答案,做完才看 :)


作者: Claire薇荇    时间: 2021-4-11 02:57
biographies' new directions - what affects subject chosen - the key question is whether an effective book can be made out of the subject's life


作者: 狒狒小姐    时间: 2021-4-11 06:02
ECC
作者: 张英俊    时间: 2021-4-11 11:26
ABA

P1: 引用观点:传记作者=自传作者
作者质疑:+ fact: RC
P2:引用观点:传记作者喜欢他们的写作对象
作者质疑:× EG. 希特勒&斯大林
P3::作者观点:传记作家需要的是客观陈述subject人生




作者: irisville    时间: 2021-4-11 16:14
dba
作者: 大大大kk    时间: 2021-4-11 17:20
观点对比
p1: 传记不等于自传
p2: 好的传记人物不等于作者认可的人+作者认定优质人物的标准:practical; personal idiosyncrasies
p3: 作者写作动力:good book
ECA
作者: LindsayPark    时间: 2021-4-11 18:55
CED
P1: 传统传记作者的样子
P2:传记作者挑选对象标准
P3:传记作者追求,写一本好书

作者: LouisTan    时间: 2021-4-11 19:51
DBA
文章结构:



作者: Jack.Lu    时间: 2021-4-11 20:23
EBA
P1:传记作家的固有印象,作者反驳
P2:写作对象的选取标准
P3:传记作家是为了写一本好书
作者: sekicc    时间: 2021-4-11 21:06
1. 引出主题
2. 举一个例子
3. 举另一个例子

ABA
作者: miemie_yang    时间: 2021-4-11 21:11
答案:E B A
大意:介绍传记是什么,传记作者寻求陌生人作为主角。传记作者对主角的态度以及选择主角时的态度以及写一本好书的感觉。
第一段:介绍传记是什么,寻找什么样的作为主角
第二段:传记作者对主题的态度
第三段:选择主题时,怎么能反映他的一生。
作者: Playgirl130    时间: 2021-4-11 21:24
P1:有一种普遍的看法,认为传记作家其实是在写自传。其实很多传记作家并不是在写自传,他们也喜欢不熟悉的事物。举例来说JP Morgan等人的传记作家RC,他形容写传记就是“踢了一个硬石子儿,一路走脚趾头都疼。”
P2:还有一种普遍的看法是,传记作家必须喜欢被写的人物。很显然,对于某些重要人物很难喜欢,比如希特勒,比如斯大林。
P3:与其说传记作家必须喜欢自己要写的人,不如说他们喜欢的是被写的“主体”,他们相信自己能写出来个好作品。
我选ABA
作者: N0ire    时间: 2021-4-11 21:25
5min
主旨:反驳2个关于自传的常见误区
P1: 有人认为传记多是自传,但实际上很多是由传记作家写就的,如RC;
P2: 有人认为传记作家必须喜欢其作传的对象,但并非如此,作传对象很纷繁,传记作家更多地出于实际考虑:可行性、时间成本、自身能力和作传对象地过人之处;
P3: 在选择作传对象时,传记作家最主要的考虑在于是否能用有限的篇幅描绘其一生的经历,促使他们努力的是希望写一本好作品而不是对作传对象的情感。

ABA
作者: 星v座v书v上    时间: 2021-4-11 22:17
CBA
作者: rs曦曦    时间: 2021-4-12 00:18
1st paragraph: a biography is not an autobiography. 需要外人的审视、挑战、质疑,让主人公感到挑战。
2nd paragraph: biographer should not like his or her subjects in person, but should like the subject as a subject. various factors determine whether a person is a good subject or not.
3rd paragraph: the main purpose of the biographer is to write an effective and good book.
作者: 速水愛媛    时间: 2021-4-12 09:05
ABA
作者: RxxMewo    时间: 2021-4-12 09:13
ABA 8min
传记一般都是关于自己的-作者观点:并不是
传记作者一般都很喜欢他们写的人-作者观点:并不是
传记作者在选择主人公时候时候真正要考虑的因素
作者: CCCGO    时间: 2021-4-12 10:18
DBA
作者: HHHHRane    时间: 2021-4-12 10:57
DBA
作者: Sibaiyuan    时间: 2021-4-12 14:20
DBA

作者: Delanii_    时间: 2021-4-12 15:46
AEA
文章结构:
P1:提出观点:并不是只有自己才能写自传,e.g. RC
P2:写自传的人对于描述对象的选取标准
p3:写自传过程中作者的写作原则
作者: ccccherry    时间: 2021-4-12 17:05
ABA
反驳两个关于传记和传记作者的观点。
作者: 半日大哥    时间: 2021-4-12 21:12
用时5分半
EEB
作者: Ataitaitai    时间: 2021-4-13 08:00
1. 通过RC来提出新的传记写法是什么样的
2. 新的传记写法具体内容
3. 总结人们对传记的写法的改变。
EBA
作者: CNJYD    时间: 2021-4-13 08:05
DBA
作者: 英语爱我我爱英语    时间: 2021-4-13 08:35
5min EDA 词汇量还是太少了
作者: sanfanwangyue    时间: 2021-4-14 11:46
EBA
作者: _Salaxy_    时间: 2021-4-14 17:00
DBA
作者: yutingw    时间: 2021-4-15 15:35
CEA
作者: 断了的弦    时间: 2021-4-15 21:25
EEBA
作者: 阿綠    时间: 2021-4-15 22:15
d
作者: JOEY要上博科尼    时间: 2021-4-17 10:14
1
作者: SchodingerCat    时间: 2021-5-5 22:45
DBA
作者: 张晴雨    时间: 2021-5-8 09:34
我的答案:EEA
正确答案:DBA
用时:8分钟
作者: 690387114    时间: 2021-6-19 10:27
DBA
题1
作者: sjj加油    时间: 2021-6-19 23:46
dba
作者: 清影嘿嘿    时间: 2021-10-25 15:56
day11

作者: 大月亮cyn    时间: 2021-10-27 17:19
Day11 DBA
作者: Chiefleung    时间: 2022-10-1 20:24
P1:介绍自传和传记的一个传统关联,然后提出反驳,用RON的例子来支持反驳的观点
P2:解释传记相关的要素。写传记者更把人物当作主题,来考虑一些因素,比如是否需要写传记,有什么事迹,需要多久能写完,被写的人有没有什么有趣的特征等
P3:描述如何选择写作对象。讲了写传记的人如何克服困难写传记,表示他们是把自己写的东西当作一本好书来写,而不是为了写而写

作者: B及站士    时间: 2023-10-7 21:10
P1: 大眾認知傳記即是自傳, 作者反駁嚴謹認真的傳記作家尋求不熟悉的題材
P2: 大眾也有一個認知"作家要喜歡傳記的主角", 作者認為作家要把傳記人物視為主題而去喜歡主題。並且討論甚麼是好的主題(列舉必要性, 素材取得, 撰寫時間, 作家本身的知識能力以及傳記人物的人格特質...)
P3: 討論如何選擇主題, 大原則為要能用書去呈現一個人物的人生 -> 結論: 作家要覺得自己在寫好書
-
P1
1. Common belief(1): biographies are autobiographies, that the biographer is always writing about himself
2. Argument: serious biographers welcome and seek the unfamiliar
3. Elaborate: Ron Chernow – encounters with unaccountable are opportunities for understanding

P2
1. Common belief(2): biographers must like their subject
2. Challenge: ruling out such vastly important subjects as Hitler orStalin – in practice, the biographer must like the subject as a subject
3. Discussion: what is good subject? – Necessities, materialsavailabilities, time, biographer’s knowledge and ability, and personalisiosyncrasies


P3
1. Elaborate: in choosing subject – can a book be made out of this person’s life
2. Conclusion: biographers’ endeavor is not affection for the subject but the feeling that they are writing a good book

作者: joliajjj    时间: 2023-12-6 09:38
文章结构:
P1:引出观点:biographies = autobiographies→作者质疑:RC
P2:引出观点:biographer喜欢他们的写作对象 质疑:H&S 列举传记需要的多方面因素
P3:观点:需要客观陈述subject的一生

DBA





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3