ChaseDream

标题: SC 700-800 一道题 求大神解答 [打印本页]

作者: 喝醉了的小猫    时间: 2019-10-15 08:49
标题: SC 700-800 一道题 求大神解答


12. Recent research has indicated that sustainable weight loss is generally a result not of self-deprivation
or adopting an extreme diet, but a healthy lifestyle that integrates a balanced diet,

regular exercise, and a long-term approach.
A. self-deprivation or adopting an extreme diet, but
B. self-deprivation or the adoption of an extreme diet, but of
C. self-deprivation or the adoption of an extreme diet, but
D. depriving oneself or adopting an extreme diet, but
E. depriving oneself or adopting an extreme diet, but that of

自己是做对了,答案是B,但是当时在B和D中间纠结了一会儿。
不考虑结构平行的关系,有没有大神能从 语法结构 层面解答一下为什么

“self-deprivation or the adoption of an extreme diet, but of” 这里 的 ”or“ 之后为什么不需要加 ”of"
完整的句子是不是应该是“self-deprivation or OF the adoption of an extreme diet, but of“


作者: EElsie    时间: 2019-10-15 09:27
or后面不应该加of呀,that后面从句的结构是 a result not of ...., but of ...
not...but...这种封闭式平行前后的平行形式要一致,所以后面的but要加上of。
至于or后面,你要看句意(毕竟句意为王),可持续的减肥不是靠自我抑制或极端节食的方法,而是靠融合了平衡膳食的健康生活方式的方法,这句是两者之间的平行,然后self-deprivation or the adoption of an extreme diet是大平行里面的小平行
如果按你的想法,结构式a result of A, or of B, but of C. 这是不对的。我记得prep语法笔记里面讲过,but只用作连接两者:A, B, but C一定错,A, or B, but C也不对
欢迎指正~

作者: 喝醉了的小猫    时间: 2019-10-15 10:03
EElsie 发表于 2019-10-15 09:27
or后面不应该加of呀,that后面从句的结构是 a result not of ...., but of ...
not...but...这种封闭式平行 ...

感谢!




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3