ChaseDream

标题: 求解两道较难的逻辑题 [打印本页]

作者: gmat700aaaaaa    时间: 2019-9-29 21:30
标题: 求解两道较难的逻辑题
来源官方难题集


作者: gmat700aaaaaa    时间: 2019-9-29 21:42
第九题是B,第四题是E
作者: Ivia雅思要考720    时间: 2019-9-30 08:43
第四题为什么选E呀?同问!有没有大大可以解释一下呢?
作者: 1998JIN    时间: 2019-9-30 13:46
同问第四题A 难道不对吗?
另,第九题琢磨了一下,应该结论是第一句话,只能选B
作者: Ivia雅思要考720    时间: 2019-9-30 14:04
我知道第一道题怎么做了。首先判断:

[P:As attorneys must cover the costs for their time and research, they want to be assured that any medical malpractice case they accept on a contingency-fee  basis has substantial merit.
SUB-C: Consequently, attorneys turn away many people who come to see  them, for lack of a good case.
C: The contingency-fee system, which allows lawyers and their clients to agree that the lawyer will be paid only in the event of success, does not increase the number of medical malpractice lawsuits brought against doctors.

gap在于sub-conclusion和conclusion之间,attorneys拒绝很多没有merits的cases就一定会导致the number of medical malpractice lawsuits does not decrease吗?如果在 The contingency-fee system后找attorneys的merit cases增加了,那么总的medical malpractice lawsuits也会增加。

(PS1:可能在看题干的时候并猜不到正确答案,但是看完了我们应该有一个思路是:在premise(attorney拒绝很多no merits cases)的情况下,哪个选项使得conclusion不成立,然后带着这个思路去判断各个选项)
(PS2:我在判断这个题的推理类型上面卡了很久,我本来认为这个是一个归因推理,但是这个思路上没有正确答案,所以最后转为因果推理来做的。我觉得这个题的推理类型判断应该是难点)
作者: AMBER513    时间: 2019-10-2 21:45
看一下!               




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3