ChaseDream

标题: OG18逻辑新题,跪求大神解释! [打印本页]

作者: Sevenas77    时间: 2017-9-20 14:36
标题: OG18逻辑新题,跪求大神解释!
The heavy traffic in Masana is a growing drain on the city's economy——the clogging of the streets of the central business district alone cost the economy more than $1.2 billion over the past year. In order to address this problem, officials plan to introduce congestion pricing, by which drivers would pay to enter the city’s most heavily trafficked areas during the busiest times of the day.
Which of the following, if true, would most strongly indicate that the plan will be a success?A Approximately one-fifth of the vehicles in the central business district are in transit from one side of the city to the other.
B Planners expect that, without congestion pricing, traffic in Masana is likely to grow by 6 percent in the next five years.
C In other urban areas, congestion pricing has strongly encouraged carpooling (sharing of rides by private commuters).
D Several studies have shown that a reduction in traffic of 15 percent in Masana could result in 5, 500 or more new jobs.
E Over 30 percent of the vehicles in the city’s center are occupied by more than one person.


求问B选项为何不对,B选项说如果不收拥堵费则未来五年交通拥堵会增加6%,不就能证明“收拥堵费”是能起作用的吗?

作者: 一抹斜阳    时间: 2017-9-20 16:07
B项只是说预期如果不收拥堵费会怎么样,但是并不等于“收了拥堵费”,交通拥堵就一定会缓解啊,会不会收费环节使得更加拥堵?
作者: Sevenas77    时间: 2017-9-20 19:44
一抹斜阳 发表于 2017-9-20 16:07
B项只是说预期如果不收拥堵费会怎么样,但是并不等于“收了拥堵费”,交通拥堵就一定会缓解啊,会不会收费 ...

哈哈,我懂啦,万分感谢!
作者: gshlucas    时间: 2019-9-11 19:05
这题我做对了,但当是在A选项上纠结了一会儿,感觉直接选C,显得这题出得没水平。后来仔细理解了一下A选项,觉得A项是削弱项。A选项说,1/5在市中心的车是因为在从城市的一边到另一边的途中。无论直接穿过市中心、还是到市中心来或从市中心走都是,都是从一边到另一边,这就说有4/5的车,也就是绝大多数只在市中心运行,不涉及进入市中心,因此收费起不到效果。




欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3