标题: 逻辑jj 第三十九篇讨论 [打印本页] 作者: 敲个木头 时间: 2016-8-6 20:32 标题: 逻辑jj 第三十九篇讨论 贴一下考古
The school introduced a bicycle loaning （注意这个bicycle loan，很关键）program which is aimed at encouraging students to ride bicycle toschools instead of driving. The school claims that the program is effectivesince 1 in 10 students ride bicycles to school now, in comparison to 1 in 100previously. And the students who drive (or take their parents’ cars) to schooldecreased from 25% to 10%.
Weaken
The choice I chose: E. most of thestudents who previously take their parents’ car to school regularly alreadyown bicycles. （理由：要weaken的关键在于attack the school’s claim that the bicycle loaning program is effective.所以E选项就说原来那些开车上学的孩子大部分本身就有自行车，所以推出借自行车根本就不可2能成为他们改骑车上学的原因，也就推翻了这个Program有效的结论。