ChaseDream

标题: OG-80 (llinkage wrong) [打印本页]

作者: wendybao 时间: 2005-6-17 09:03
标题: OG-80 (llinkage wrong)
80.The program to control the entry of illegal drugs into the country was a failure in 1987. If the program had been successful, the wholesale price of most illegal drugs would not have dropped substantially in 1987.

The argument in the passage depends on which of the following assumptions?

(A) The supply of illegal drugs dropped substantially in 1987.

(B) The price paid for most illegal drugs by the average consumer did not drop substantially in 1987.

(D) The wholesale price of a few illegal drugs increased substantially in 1987. E

(E) A drop in demand for most illegal drugs in 1987 was not the sole cause of the drop in their wholesale price.

80.

The only choice that must be true in order to conclude legitimately from the drop in the wholesale price of illegal drugs that the program was a failure is choice E, the best answer. If the drop in price was caused by a drop in demand, there is no reason to suspect that there has been any increase in supply caused by drugs entering the country.

The other choices can be false without affecting the argument. The supply of illegal drugs need not have dropped (choice A), and the retail price could have dropped (choice B). The entry of illegal drugs could have risen at a higher rate than domestic production (choice C), and no illegal drug need have undergone a substantial price rise (choice D).

看OG关于E的解释怎么样也看不出个所以然

还有A为何不正确？

作者: liliy4gmat 时间: 2005-6-17 15:31

价格会下降影响的因素一个是供给增多（管制失败导致），另一个是需求增加。

所以a恰好是反的。

如果不是承认了还有其他的因素引起了价格的下跌，那么那个管制成功与否与价格都是没有关系的

not+weaken

作者: welkin 时间: 2005-6-20 15:49

OG的解释是用原文结论的逆否命题来说的（不知道为什么ETS非要用逆否命题来解释），原文结论是“计划成果推出价格不下降”，解释中说The only choice that must be true in order to conclude legitimately from the drop in the wholesale price of illegal drugs that the program was a failure ，说的是“价格下降推出计划失败” 其实和原文是一回事。个人觉得这题没必要用逆否命题。

此题的解体思路是，原文结论为条件结果，对结论的假设就是，排除充分条件出现，结果不出现的情况，排除其他因数会导致结果不出现，或者是条件一定能推出结果（lawyer NN 在他的文章中讲过，建议你仔细体会一下lawyer的文章），而E就是在排除“在计划成果的情况下，demand的下降使价格下降”

作者: 无路可退 时间: 2005-6-24 18:11

there are 2 main reasons cause the wholesale price deline : the drop of demand or the increasing of supply.

the anwser E said:A drop in demand for most illegal drugs in 1987 was not the sole cause of the drop in their wholesale price

from this assumption, the conclusion can be inferred is: the increasing of supply is the sole cause.which conclude that the contral program is failure on contral.

2楼的DX有个笔误，是需求减少，而不是增加。如果需求增加会导致价格升高。

作者: EASYSUMMER 时间: 2005-7-2 06:31

from this assumption, the conclusion can be inferred is: the increasing of supply is the sole cause.which conclude that the contral program is failure on contral.

请问楼上的朋友，这个结论如何得出。。

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)