ChaseDream

标题: 大全197 [打印本页]

作者: x4444 时间: 2005-4-2 23:43
标题: 大全197

197. Camus broke with Sartre in a bitter dispute over the nature of Stalinism.

(A) in a bitter dispute over

(B) over bitterly disputing

(D) after having bitterly disputed about（A）

(E) over a bitter dispute about

A 是固定用法吗？berak .... in...???

有没有dispute about 的用法？我记得有对吗？

作者: jerjer 时间: 2005-4-3 10:26

in 和break 没有关系，in + a bitter dispute

dispute作为名词时:a : verbal controversy : DEBATE b : QUARREL 我们可以使用a dispute about sth.

但当dispute 作为VI ：to engage in argument : DEBATE; especially : to argue irritably or with irritating persistence

我们一般使用dispute over sth

作者: x4444 时间: 2005-4-3 19:59
ooo 总算有的明白了。谢了jerjer

作者: titatita 时间: 2006-3-6 08:39

以下是引用jerjer在2005-4-3 10:26:00的发言：

in 和break 没有关系，in + a bitter dispute

dispute作为名词时:a : verbal controversy : DEBATE b : QUARREL 我们可以使用a dispute about sth.

但当dispute 作为VI ：to engage in argument : DEBATE; especially : to argue irritably or with irritating persistence

我们一般使用dispute over sth

but the dispute here is a noun.

作者: smileday 时间: 2006-6-26 13:58

以下是引用x4444在2005-4-2 23:43:00的发言：

197. Camus broke with Sartre in a bitter dispute over the nature of Stalinism.

(A) in a bitter dispute over

(B) over bitterly disputing

(D) after having bitterly disputed about（A）

(E) over a bitter dispute about

I pick A too.

but, what's wrong with E ??

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-6-27 19:46:42编辑过]

作者: madben 时间: 2006-7-1 12:05

以下是引用smileday在2006-6-26 13:58:00的发言：

I pick A too.

but, what's wrong with E ??

A break with B Over a dispute 可能有点怪。他们是在关于S的争论中闹翻的，而不是在这个争论之上。

作者: slickwx 时间: 2006-7-1 12:39
标题: 我感觉IN在这里有因为的意思.而OVER没有

我感觉IN在这里有因为的意思.而OVER没有

作者: sarybaby 时间: 2008-3-31 23:11

以下是引用jerjer在2005-4-3 10:26:00的发言：

in 和break 没有关系，in + a bitter dispute

dispute作为名词时:a : verbal controversy : DEBATE b : QUARREL 我们可以使用a dispute about sth.

但当dispute 作为VI ：to engage in argument : DEBATE; especially : to argue irritably or with irritating persistence

我们一般使用dispute over sth

强人！！！一定要顶一下！！！！

作者: szy733 时间: 2008-6-17 15:20

我觉得此题更多的应该从句意上解释，文中的原意应该是Camus与 Sartre在一场关于斯大林主义的争论里决裂。所以显然应该用in

作者: amorela 时间: 2008-9-2 11:55

ding .

作者: AlienX 时间: 2008-9-2 13:57
umm...OG上是說break+in...

作者: heritta 时间: 2009-1-15 16:40

以下是引用titatita在2006-3-6 8:39:00的发言：

but the dispute here is a noun.

好像在哪看到说【关于...（的内容）】都应该是用介词about的，所以做的时候把over先排除了。

查了朗文后dispute作名词有这些用法：dispute over是固定搭配

a serious argument or disagreement
dispute with
　The firm is involved in a legal dispute with a rival company.
dispute over
　He got into a dispute over a taxi fare.【对a taxi fare的争论】
　Every effort was made to settle the dispute , but without success.
dispute between
　the bitter border dispute between the countries

作者: Hattielin87 时间: 2010-7-17 15:54
我不明白前辈的说法啊。在这道题中，dispute前面有一个a来修饰，明显是一个名词嘛。按照前辈的说法，岂不是后面要加about？？不太明白这个说法。而且解释里面说 the idiomatic form of expression is broke..in, not broke…over。也就是说，broke...in....才是固定用法？

in 和break 没有关系，in + a bitter dispute
dispute作为名词时:a : verbal controversy : DEBATE b : QUARREL 我们可以使用a dispute about sth.
但当dispute 作为VI ：to engage in argument : DEBATE; especially : to argue irritably or with irritating persistence
我们一般使用dispute over sth

-- by 会员 jerjer (2005/4/3 10:26:00)

作者: anythink 时间: 2010-7-26 20:30
dispute 做名词用over，做动词时用 dispute (something) with somebodychasedream 的2楼刚好回答反了

作者: appleontree 时间: 2010-9-9 00:41
弱弱的问一句,c为什么不对呢？

作者: DeliciaAn 时间: 2015-3-16 11:23
以下引用RonPurewal from http://www.manhattanprep.com/gmat/forums/1000sc-197-t1364.html

Make sure that you appreciate the difference in meaning between the two sentences. If you say that C broke with S in a bitter dispute, you are saying that, during the course of the dispute, the 'break' occurred. If you say they broke over a bitter dispute, you are actually saying that they didn't break during the dispute itself, but rather that the dispute was the catalyst of their later (although probably not too much later) 'break'.

Given all this, only the first makes sense: C and S are not quarreling lovers who 'broke up' over their little dispute (as is suggested by choice E). Rather, they 'broke' ideologically from each other in the bitter dispute, but we don't know anything about how, or indeed if, the 'bitter dispute' affected their personal relationship.

作者: DeliciaAn 时间: 2015-3-16 11:29

DeliciaAn 发表于 2015-3-16 11:23
以下引用RonPurewal from http://www.manhattanprep.com/gmat/forums/1000sc-197-t1364.html

这里总结一下ron神的解释：
A broke with B in a bitter dispute: A和B在争吵中决裂了（分手broke up with?仍须证实）
A broke with B over a bitter dispute: A和B 在争吵后决裂，即－>争吵是决裂的诱因

根据语义能确定的是争吵影响了C和S间的关系

欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/)