unlike后面可以加 动名词吗？

坤kun

Unlike using spices for cooking, in medicinal usage they are taken in large quantities in order to

treat particular maladies.

(A) Unlike using spices for cooking, in medicinal usage they are taken

(B) Unlike spices that are used in cooking, in using spices for medicine, they are taken

(C) Unlike cooking with spices, taking spices for medicinal use is done

(D) In cooking, small quantities of spices are used, whereas in medicinal usage spices are taken

(E) In cooking, the usage of spices is in small quantities, whereas in medicinal usage they are taken

我一直以为unlike只能加 名词 或者 名词短语 ， 不能加 动名词、介词短语、从句
但是看到这个题的讨论帖的时候好像有人说unlike using也是正确的，到底unlike可以加ing吗？
谢谢啦！

jameshzd

unlike 是不能加 doing 滴， unlike used to contrast sb/sth with another person or thing , 不能对某种抽象的形式进行对比，by the way , is E the best answer?

坤kun

unlike 是不能加 doing 滴， unlike used to contrast sb/sth with another person or thing , 不能对某种抽象的形式进行对比，by the way , is E the best answer?

-- by 会员 jameshzd (2011/5/31 21:16:42)

哈~了解！ OA是D，据说E是错在they指代不清~可以指代spices也可以指代quantities

jameshzd

哎呀！失误，D选项的spices 被我看掉了。。。

MAYG12345

选D
RON:
choice e literally says that the usage of spices is 'in small quantities', which is not the proper message. this could mean that you don't use spices very often, but, when you do, you dump 14 kilos of allspice and 12 kilos of paprika in your pan.

the sentence needs to convey the message that the spices are the things of which quantities are small. choice d conveys this message well.

one could say that d isn't 100% parallel, but it's definitely more parallel than the other choices: in cooking, (noun) is used (passive voice construction); in medicinal usage, (noun) are taken (passive voice construction).

brendaw

顶楼主！               

earn_it

关于unlike后面能不能加动名词，依然疑惑
学生问：Does that mean we can say "like/unlike Ving, Ving is..."? e.g. Like reading novels in Central Park, riding a bike in Central Park is Jane's favorite activity. I know "like/unlike" is used to compare nouns but I'm not sure whether "like/unlike" can be used to compare Ving-form nouns. Thanks.

RON回答:Those nouns are ok, too.

liuziyang123

earn_it 发表于 2017-3-22 20:29
关于unlike后面能不能加动名词，依然疑惑
学生问：Does that mean we can say "like/unlike Ving, Ving is. ...

同意！               

liuziyang123

liuziyang123 发表于 2018-1-19 21:53
同意！

同意！               

顿东w

看一下！