GWD26-Q18看完讨论之后还是不明白，请NN指点

alex2610

还是觉得E不好啊，怎么能推到any extant mm的啊？。。。郁闷。。谁来解答下了。。。。

sdcar2010

extant: still in existence; not extinct or destroyed or lost

The answer is E becasue the Electra is one of the alphabeticals, one of the eight works appear in alphabetical order without commentary.

fiatlux

A
B
C
D
E

F 以上皆不对


实在没有道理是E的，如果没有提的就可以assume就不是逻辑题啦

眼不见心不烦 我打算叉掉这道题～ ^^

sdcar2010

An old book L contains all 18 extant books by God.  Of these, ten of them called "selected books" are accompanied by ancient commentaries in book L and also appear in other old books. The other eight in alphabetical order, without commentary. Bible is one of the alphabeticals.

Bible does not appear accompanied by a commentary in any extant old books. Otherwise, Bible would have been among the "selected books."

Poodle1223

An old book L contains all 18 extant books by God.  Of these, ten of them called "selected books" are accompanied by ancient commentaries in book L and also appear in other old books. The other eight in alphabetical order, without commentary. Bible is one of the alphabeticals.

Bible does not appear accompanied by a commentary in any extant old books. Otherwise, Bible would have been among the "selected books."

就是这个理 ，注意 are accompanied in L by ancient commentaries and also appear in other medieval manuscripts; 如果 EE 不是 Select book ， EE 则是 NOT ancient commentaries and also NOT appear in other medieval manuscripts

crown48

很早之前被大家讨论的题，我今天做错了，最后想通了，所以来发表下我的意见

18.
GWD26-Q18

A medieval manuscript called L contains all eighteen extant tragedies by the Greek playwright Euripides. Of these, ten called the “select plays,” are accompanied in L by ancient commentaries and also appear in other medieval manuscripts; this group includes some of Euripides’ best-known works, including the Medea. The other eight, which appear in alphabetical order, without commentary. The Electra is one of the alphabeticals.

L中10本选集，有评论，出现在其他手稿中

包括部分的最好作品，其中有M

8个首字母排序文，没有评论

包括E

Which of the following can be reliably concluded on the basis of the Statements given?

A.     Only Euripides’ best-known works are accompanied by ancient commentaries in extant medieval manuscripts.

有评论的有10本，其中部分是最好作品，所以一定有不是最好作品的作品是有评论的

B.     The select plays are accompanied by ancient commentaries because they were the best known of Euripides’ works.    无关选项，没说有评论的原因

C.     No commentaries were written about Euripides’ Electra in ancient times.

L中的E没有评论，不表示E从来没有评论

D.    Euripides’ Medea never appears in medieval manuscripts unaccompanied by ancient commentary.

在L中的M是有评论的，不代表M在所有手稿中都有评论

E.     Euripides’ Electra does not appear accompanied by a commentary in any extant medieval manuscript.

首先，E出现在L中，但是没有评论

其次，E没有出现在过其他的手稿中

综上，E在所有的手稿中都没有伴随评论出现过

-- by 会员 zxj191401 (2009/9/17 21:09:00)

好解释！thx

灰灰糖

主要还是不要拐弯。。。

jaze

还是不懂
accompanied by ancient commentaries in book L and also appear in other old books
对其取非的话， 是不是有以下几种可能
1  not accompanied and also appear in ..     对EE有可能啊
2  accompanied by and not appear in other ..   对EE没有可能， 因为EE没有commantaries
3  not accompanied and not appear in               对EE也有可能啊
我觉着从文中只能明确的看出来， EE没有在selective里面， 因为它没有commantaries， 但是它有没有出现在其它书里面，并不知道啊

这里我认为一个关键点就是  在L里但是不在selective里面， 那会不会出现在其它old books里面，
从正确答案来看， 他们选的是第三种
可是， 第一种可能性是怎么排除的？还是我的理解有问题？

万不得已把老帖顶出来， 因为实在是没明白，希望会的人， 讲讲，谢谢

kikisunflower

经过多次对取非的尝试，血泪的经验告诉我，除了assumption的题以外，千万不要取非。。。顺着想。。。一定要顺着想。。。。

顺着想，这道题就很简单了。。千万不要取非。。

jaze

怎么顺着想啊？