答关于finance journals 排名及一些publication的情况

金融

其实也没啥。这些人换个稍微差点的学校立马tenure。硬通货在手啊。赫赫

for top 10 schools, a number of A pubs is a minimum requirement, but no guarantee. 非常难讲他们会tenure 什么人, kick out 什么人. 他们基本上会claim they want their APs to do research with large impact in the prfession before they get tenured. 但是什么是large impact research, 非常主观. 无数牛人被top school kicked out. For example, the current RFS executive editor 当年被columbia 开了。WFA past president and RFS past editor wayne ferson没有办法在芝加哥tenure even he had 10+ A publications. 最近的一个例子是martin cremers of yale. he has 10+ As 但是他没有tenure. 所以top school tenure case 很难讲。。。

very nice post!!!

btw, what is the requirement for tenure promotion in top 10 school? Do you think ppl like Joshua Rauh can get tenured at uchicago if he stayed there for another 2 or 3 years?

-- by 会员 kndx5 (2011/3/20 11:43:34)

-- by 会员 xiaotian24 (2011/3/20 11:53:09)

dicanio

赞硬通货，发2篇Ajournal，可以招摇撞骗一辈子了~~

xiaotian24

呵呵, 我assume你说的“发2篇Ajournal，可以招摇撞骗一辈子了”是在国内。不过这也许在十年以前可以， 现在中国人发A journal paper越来越多了。我看没个5+ As，在国内招摇撞骗一时可以， 招摇撞骗一辈子就不大可能了。。。

赞硬通货，发2篇Ajournal，可以招摇撞骗一辈子了~~

-- by 会员 dicanio (2011/3/20 23:05:17)

xiaotian24

smir sufi刚拿到了另一家top school的offer ，是哪个学校就不说了。不过目前不知道他是自愿跳槽， 还是tenure出了问题，被迫的。他做的确实非常不错。

neng wang 做的离我的比较远， 很难judge他的 paper的impact,但是看上去他有AER and a couple of single-authored JME in his early career, which is very good record...

那看来即使是amir sufi那样的说不好在chicago也拿不到tenure了

那你说neng wang呢，在columbia 拿到full prof的时候一共也没几篇solid A，是因为paper的质量比较高？

[

- by 会员 kndx5 (2011/3/20 12:16:04)

VNMS

Amir got an offer from MIT.

kndx5

是直接full还是tenured associate？

Amir got an offer from MIT.

-- by 会员 VNMS (2011/3/21 9:28:44)

qiqijiajia

[quote]
很多top 学校要求至少有一篇single-authored 的A publication for a successful tenure case. 即使是co-authored 的papers, it matters if it is coauthored with peer colleagues/phd students or it is co-authored with seniors/advisors/big names. 如果是前者，discount 会很小，如果是后者，discount会很大。[quote]

别说评tenure阿，就算申请phd和senior professor 写也要被discount。。。惨阿。还是lz厉害，single author阿。

VNMS

Tenured Associate

Oliver19000

Can you share about why you think JFQA is 4th for sure? I heard from people that citation for JFQA has been declining for these years and make it less and less attractive.Thanks.

fzxc613

how about JCM