ChaseDream

标题: 揽瓜阁阅读做题小分队 第84天 哲学家Whitehead [打印本页]

作者: 小白斩鸡    时间: 2021-6-22 06:38
标题: 揽瓜阁阅读做题小分队 第84天 哲学家Whitehead
请大家在本帖回复:
1. 文章大概结构
2. 自己写的答案

解析+文章翻译明晚微信群里公布

报名活动,加微信号killgmat




Metaphysics – the philosophical investigation of the nature of the universe and existence – had become unfashionable by the time Alfred North Whitehead began writing in earnest about it in the 1920s. The ever-more impressive accomplishments of empirical science had led to a general consensus in academia that the development of comprehensive metaphysical systems was a waste of time because they were not subject to empirical testing.

Whitehead was unimpressed by this objection. In Whitehead's view, scientists and philosophers make metaphysical assumptions about how the universe works all the time, but such assumptions are not easily seen precisely because they remain unexamined and unquestioned. Perhaps foremost among what Whitehead considered faulty metaphysical assumptions was the idea of substance materialism, which he rejected in favor of an opposite, event-based “process" ontology in which transient events are primary and material substances/beings are abstractions. He also argued that the most basic elements of reality have experiential features, that in fact everything is constituted by its experience (i.e., even things like electrons experience). Whitehead referred to his metaphysical system as "philosophy of organism," but it would become known more widely as "process philosophy."

This philosophy of Whitehead was highly original, and soon garnered interest in philosophical circles. After publishing The Concept of Nature in 1920, he served as president of the Aristotelian Society from 1922 to 1923, and Henri Bergson was quoted as saying that Whitehead was "the best philosopher writing in English." So impressive and different was Whitehead's philosophy that in 1924 he was invited to join the faculty at Harvard University as a professor of philosophy at 63 years of age, even though his educational background was in a very different field.


1. It can be inferred from the passage that those adhering to the idea of “substance materialism” would view material substances and beings as:
(A) abstract
(B) concrete
(C) event-based
(D) experiential
(E) process-driven


2. The primary purpose of this passage is to:
(A) highlight one unique contribution of an important philosopher.
(B) discuss the importance of metaphysics as a field in science.
(C) provide details on the concept of “process philosophy.”
(D) emphasize Whitehead’s place among other philosophers.
(E) prove that “process philosophy” was superior to “substance materialism.”


3. Which one of the following perspectives would best capture Whitehead’s “process philosophy”?
(A) A building is viewed through its size, materials, and aesthetics.
(B) A car is viewed through its horsepower, design, and speed.
(C) A school is viewed through its students, teachers, and staff.
(D) A business is viewed through its mission, advertising, and headquarters.
(E) A person is viewed through his experiences, interactions, and memories.


4. The author would most likely describe Whitehead’s philosophy in the early 1920s as:
(A) highly controversial
(B) unimpressive
(C) never before considered
(D) poorly understood
(E) unique and respected


5. The author of the passage would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
(A) Metaphysics is a field worthy of considerably more attention and respect.
(B) Alfred North Whitehead was successful as a challenger of conventional wisdom.
(C) Empirical science is a more respected field than is metaphysics.
(D) Alfred North Whitehead was a controversial figure among academics in the early 20th century.
(E) Alfred North Whitehead restored the prestige of metaphysics as an academic subject.


参考答案:


作者: 断了的弦    时间: 2021-6-22 08:15
EAAEB
作者: YY-Y    时间: 2021-6-22 10:40
BDEEA
作者: CaryX    时间: 2021-6-22 10:53
Mark一下!               
作者: yutingw    时间: 2021-6-22 16:35
Mark一下!               
作者: 再战请勿拦    时间: 2021-6-22 20:09
1 B 08:31
2 A 00:18
3 E 01:17
4 C 00:24
5 E 01:02

作者: ybmg    时间: 2021-6-22 21:49
AAEBB
作者: vincentm9426    时间: 2021-6-22 22:44
看一下!               
作者: 飞跃重洋2017    时间: 2021-6-23 00:24
BAEBE
作者: 2021加油冲    时间: 2021-6-23 00:28
谢谢
作者: famerica    时间: 2021-6-23 11:59
baeea
作者: Syvlia    时间: 2021-6-23 22:28
AAEEA
作者: 山言寺林    时间: 2021-6-23 22:52
1. 1920年W刚开始写他的作品的时候,M这一理论被认为是过时了的,批评者的观点是M和empirical testing不符
2. 详细说明W的观点,他提出process philosophy,认为有实体的物质都是基于抽象的东西,或者说experience based的
3. 后来他的理论引起了哲学圈的人的注意,收获人们的尊敬
BAEEE
作者: Blanche会努力    时间: 2021-6-24 11:01
ABECD
作者: 690387114    时间: 2021-6-25 18:08
BAECB答案BAEEB



作者: jiajiajiayi    时间: 2021-6-29 13:22
BAEEB
作者: iamvv    时间: 2021-10-9 21:48
AAEEA
1:玄学在W时代不流行
2:W对玄学的定义修正-基于过程而非物质
3:W的评价
作者: Fromager    时间: 2023-9-8 22:14
BAEEB
作者: 屯个名字    时间: 2023-9-16 21:13
P1:Metaphysics现状
ANW开始钻研写作时Metaphysics已经不流行了
——>更流行的是empirical science,因为Metaphysics不可以实证检验

P2:ANW反对现状
ANW反对现状
——>(为什么/他怎么想?)ANW认为科学家对于Metaphysics的假设是有问题的
——>(什么问题/他的观点)
1.ANW反对Metaphysics中的substance materialism
2.支持相反的、基于事件的“过程”本体论,其中短暂事件是主要的,物质物质/存在是抽象的
3.万物由经验构成

P3:ANW及 philosophy of Whitehead的成就


BCEEB 9’38”
作者: andyhhhh    时间: 2023-9-21 20:52
一、描述一種理論曾不被歡迎
Meta在1920時期,白頭出現之前,是不被歡迎的理論,因為學術界認為這是一個很浪費時間的系統,因為其不從事實證測試

二、哲學家白頭反對這個反對
白頭認為科學家們一直都有做假設,但這些假設不容易被看見,因為他們沒有被檢驗或測試。或許白頭認為最為錯誤的假設是物質質化論,這理論主張短暫事件是主要的,而物質是抽象的。他也主張基本元素也有實務特徵,任何事物都是以經驗組成。白頭說這套系統是生物哲學,後來被稱為程序哲學。

三、白頭是獨特且被當時讚揚的
他的理論是原創的也很快得到當時的重視,發布文章後,他被選為組織的會長,也被同儕讚揚,後來也被哈佛邀請當教授,
儘管他的背景沒有很相關。

AADEB





欢迎光临 ChaseDream (https://forum.chasedream.com/) Powered by Discuz! X3.3